The pioneering computer scientist on why Trump is using ‘superintelligence’ wrong, whether AI could wipe out humanity – and how our biggest challenge will be accepting we’re not the only intelligent beings
I’m pretty sure comprehension was like the original success of LLMs, and the responses were a bit wonky. When was the last time an LLM failed to comprehend?
LLM’s comprehend statistical correlations. If you feed it every chess game, it can tell you which spaces the knight is likely to move to, and which it very unlikely to move to, but it does not understand how the knight moves.
You might say that’s a distinction without a difference, but programs can actually know thing, like a chess program actually does know how a knight moves, and it does so with minimal electricity.
I really feel like yall spend too much time focusing on the how, and not the results. Was the analysis of chess moves useful? Great then it’s a good tool. Even better you found the limitation of the tool. That would make you a better user of the tool.
I approached the topic asking “ can the tool do real world work?” Or “can I use the tool to benefit myself?” Or even “ am I enjoying learning how to use the tool”
A piece of software that cost $20 a month and can help me create a game I can play and share with my friends in under 10 days. Pretty cool if you ask me. I learning how to make a video game felt good, the result is real, I’m going to make another one.
And to be fair they know exactly how the game works… they trained my ais and programmed my game. I don’t know how my game works.
They never comprehend. They ingest information and find close approximations for responses, but they don’t comprehend any part of the process. If they did, they wouldn’t hallucinate complete bullshit answers and spit them out like they were fact
Define intelligence.
Comprehension, something LLMs are intrinsically incapable of demonstrating, let alone possessing.
I’m pretty sure comprehension was like the original success of LLMs, and the responses were a bit wonky. When was the last time an LLM failed to comprehend?
LLM’s comprehend statistical correlations. If you feed it every chess game, it can tell you which spaces the knight is likely to move to, and which it very unlikely to move to, but it does not understand how the knight moves.
You might say that’s a distinction without a difference, but programs can actually know thing, like a chess program actually does know how a knight moves, and it does so with minimal electricity.
I really feel like yall spend too much time focusing on the how, and not the results. Was the analysis of chess moves useful? Great then it’s a good tool. Even better you found the limitation of the tool. That would make you a better user of the tool.
I approached the topic asking “ can the tool do real world work?” Or “can I use the tool to benefit myself?” Or even “ am I enjoying learning how to use the tool”
A piece of software that cost $20 a month and can help me create a game I can play and share with my friends in under 10 days. Pretty cool if you ask me. I learning how to make a video game felt good, the result is real, I’m going to make another one.
And to be fair they know exactly how the game works… they trained my ais and programmed my game. I don’t know how my game works.
You gotta use the right tool for the job. Using AI to play chess is like using a sledge hammer to drive a finishing nail.
For programming, LLM AI is a great tool, no doubt.
They never comprehend. They ingest information and find close approximations for responses, but they don’t comprehend any part of the process. If they did, they wouldn’t hallucinate complete bullshit answers and spit them out like they were fact
Silence luddite lmaoo. All of ur jobs r mine