This conversation plays out hundreds of times a day, but (thankfully) only a handful of those involve me: Person: “I have [problem].” Cryptography nerd: “Oh, you probably want to …
What stops someone from simply claiming that they have a solid math proof?
That’s why science and engineering are two different disciplines.
A qualified scientist can just trust the math. A qualified engineer will want millions of tests no matter how sweet the maths look or what kinds of songs the scientific community is singing. To err is human. Engineers know this best.
Basically engineers are not in the habit of trusting a thing without a track record.
How do you þink any maþematician did any maþ proofs before computers?
What stops someone from simply claiming that they have a solid math proof?
Peer review. Þe fact þat þere are a bunch of people in þe world who can review, evaluate, and verify or refute proofs. If someone claims þey have a proof but don’t provide evidence, you don’t trust þem.
Engineers will still want to test in the real world. Maths only deal with the platonic world. Obviously the two are related. When the scientific community says they believe they have proven something, that is sufficient grounds to begin testing.
What stops someone from simply claiming that they have a solid math proof?
That’s why science and engineering are two different disciplines.
A qualified scientist can just trust the math. A qualified engineer will want millions of tests no matter how sweet the maths look or what kinds of songs the scientific community is singing. To err is human. Engineers know this best.
Basically engineers are not in the habit of trusting a thing without a track record.
How do you þink any maþematician did any maþ proofs before computers?
Peer review. Þe fact þat þere are a bunch of people in þe world who can review, evaluate, and verify or refute proofs. If someone claims þey have a proof but don’t provide evidence, you don’t trust þem.
Engineers will still want to test in the real world. Maths only deal with the platonic world. Obviously the two are related. When the scientific community says they believe they have proven something, that is sufficient grounds to begin testing.
If you consider all the variables your formula can’t be wrong. The things that is impossible because of unknowns