• Zarobi@aussie.zone
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    6 days ago

    If it wasn’t to confuse people, they could just show both bits and bytes. There’s no reason not to. I’ve seen this occasionally with ethical ISPs who care about their customers (extremely rare) - they would display it like this:

    Typical evening speed: 25Mbps (approx 3 megabytes per second)

    Almost everyone I know who isn’t in tech is extremely confused by this distinction. Absolutely they keep the bigger number because it directly benefits them. If they’re offering the 3 speed, but competitors are offering the 25 speed, of course customers want the bigger number! Normies don’t even know what a bit is.

    I don’t particularly think the historical value of a byte is really relevant either. It’s been 8 bits for half a century now.

    Since 1975 or so, the word byte has come to mean a sequence of precisely eight binary digits

    I don’t think it’s a big deal or a hill to die on or anything. Since everyone does it, at least it’s consistent. But the industry is kind of shooting themselves in the foot because they get ten thousand service desk calls per day complaining about slow internet speeds that are less than one eighth of the advertised number.

    • Potato Lover 💾 No brain found@lemmy.sdf.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      edit-2
      5 days ago

      they could just show both bits and bytes

      But what prefix? You could end up showing 4 units: Megabits, Mebibits, Megabytes and Mebibytes. Although there’s also the JEDEC 100B.01, under which binary prefix is used with KB, MB, GB, TB, where the only clear difference is between kB and KB.
      In that case, you get the insane 1TB = ~1.1TB or 1TB = ~0.9TB that you see on Windows.

      My favorite example of unit confusion is the “1.44MB floppy”, which is neither true in MB, nor MiB, because it’s actually 1,440KiB, so it’s either ~1.47MB or ~1.41MiB.